Pogo said, "we have met the enemy, and he is us." One of the things that troubles me about the current Alberta referendum is that it feeds the narrative that there is "us" and "them", and "them" can be treated differently. Once you start down that road it becomes difficult to stop.
Deny 'them' jobs, then restrict healthcare and education to 'them', tax 'them' more, demand more onerous and expensive paperwork for 'them' to access to basic services, all as solutions to problems that don't really exist. It goes downhill from there, with recent historical examples that I hope I don't need to go into.
'Them' can cover a lot of ground. Immigrants from abroad or other parts of Canada. People with black or brown skin. Any of LGBTQIA2S+. People that vote Liberal or NDP. People with drug addictions or mental illness. The homeless. Jews have been 'them' for centuries, but Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus, and even atheists can be 'them' as well. This isn't new, of course. Outsiders have been demonized since forever. It's sad and upsetting to see it here.
OK, that bit was written in early October. The Alberta referendum is over and what a waste of $84,000,000 that was. The idea of Alberta separating was rejected 75 to 25. I remain baffled that many people think emulating a three year old threatening to hold his breath till he turns blue is a good negotiating strategy.
After courting the separatists, the UCP is now trying to brand itself as a unified party supporting a "strong Alberta within a united Canada". Not a separatist party. The separatists have been invited get with the program, or form their own party. Good luck with that. Needless to say, some of them are sulking. They 'missed it by that much' (channeling Maxwell Smart) in taking over the UCP and having full reign to implement their nihilist agenda. Some of them still don't quite believe it won't happen. If it somehow ever happened, it would make Trump and Putin smile.
I'd actually like to see a separatist party formed, and try to run an election campaign. One issue candidates don't tend to fare well in elections. Running a city, a province, a country is far more complicated than people think. There are real issues to be dealt with, and none of them are black and white. One of my buddies celebrated retiring from the IT industry, saying all the easy projects have been done. Much of the so-called progress is just a remixing of the same solution in a different skin. It's a safe bet in politics to say that if it were easy, it would have been done already.
The remaining questions were less clear cut. To start with, you ask a nonsense question, you're going to get a nonsense answer. The questions relating to changing the Constitution are complete non-starters. The reality of Canadian politics is that the required levels of agreement to change the Constitution are not going to happen. Why waste your time? Learn to work within the system.
The remaining questions just expose the bigotry of the ruling party. Stir up fear of 'them', in an attempt to distract the voters from their own incompetence. That's a tall order, but they're trying. If they put that much effort into actually governing to deal with the issues of many Albertans in a fact-based approach, they'd probably be doing ok in the polling. Instead, they merely pander to their base.
Think about it. Trudeau (senior and junior) and Liberal are swear words in much of Alberta. Ask many people their opinion on those topics and you'd best be standing well upwind. The NDP (provincially or federally) doesn't fare much better. This is mainly because there is a constant drumbeat of negativity about them. The various flavours of conservatives here are actually only united in the sense of keeping the Liberals and NDP out of power, but that's a blog for another day. As a side note, Pierre Trudeau left office in 1984. That's last week for some people.
Various flavours of conservative parties have run Alberta for nearly 90 years, with about 15 years of actual competence during the 70's and early 80's, and with a short interregnum NDP government from 2015 to 2019. This was a difficult time to be in government, and the NDP got blamed for what was really the fallout from global issues. That the federal NDP supported Justin Trudeau, is enough to taint the provincial NDP with the Trudeau baggage, even more so than the NDP are socialists which means communist. Which is a whole other blog. It's fair to say that Nenshi (current leader of the provincial NDP) has his own baggage to carry.
I find it amusing that the UCP constantly tells the federal government to 'stay in their own lane' and give them money without any oversight. Then they go and meddle in municipal politics to tell the cities how to run things based on their ideological biases. See bike lanes and the green line.
We're sort of in a holding pattern here. A year to the provincial election, and the UCP is consumed with getting it's own house in order, not actually governing. The federal Liberals are getting on with things, signing trade deals and building relationships to lessen our dependence on the USA, but the results will take time to kick in.
As an aside, I think Carney is doing a great job under difficult circumstances, dealing with a petulant bully and a dysfunctional Congress and Senate during the lame duck period between the elections and taking office. I strongly suspect the major activity in the Republican party right now is shredding a lot of paper.
Then again, even after the Democrats take office, things aren't likely to improve much. The USA is a failed empire swirling around the toilet bowl. China, with all the human rights abuses, spying issues, and imperial ambitions to make up for a century of humiliation, is looking like the steady and responsible party in all this.
My take? I try to limit my intake of news. Usually the headline tells me all I need to know, and much more is bad for my blood pressure. There isn't anything I can really do about it. "Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups." Which is the problem of AI in a nutshell, which is a whole other blog.
What do I do instead? I'm busy with my community association. The problems are on a human scale. Me, the exec, board, and staff can usually figure them out, and within some limits come up with solutions. (As a digression, one of the exceptions was when the UCP distributed rules about dealing with COVID back in the day. The exec of the time read the rules and tried to come to grips with how to follow them. Five mature people with lots of life experience could not make sense of what we were and were not allowed to do.) We can usually see the effect on our community, and hopefully we got it right. If not we can change course and adapt. I find it very satisfying, even if there are some people we can't help.
I just got back from strolling the craft sale at St Jude school. It's a short walk away so I decided to get out to see if there was anyone I know. There was, but considering he lives across the street that wasn't a big surprise. The big surprise was to have a little girl maybe 9 or 10 years old ask if I was a photographer. I'm not kidding. We chatted a bit, and she remembered me taking photos at a skate with Santa a couple years ago. Here, if you're curious, she is one of the kids. I chatted with the mom about her thoughts of living here. It's great to hear we're doing stuff right.
Of the day photos will return.




















































